Be the first to review this product
Amish Poly Replica Fire Island Lighthouse
Additional Information
| Handcrafted In | Pennsylvania, USA |
|---|---|
| Availability | 3 - 4 weeks |
| Collection | Amish Garden Lighthouses |
| Lighthouse Style | Replica |
| Replicas | Fire Island |
| Weight | 45 |
| Note | 4-foot and larger lighthouses require very minor assembly |
| Maintenance | Poly top and base never need painting. |
| Material | Poly Lumber |
| Warranty | This woodworker stands behind his work and will offer replacements for any manufacturer defects |
| Assembly | No Assembly Required |
| Shipping | Free Shipping |
| Shipping Regions | Ships to USA excluding Hawaii and Alaska |
| Condition | New |
Details
Black-and-white bands from the tallest lighthouse in New York.
The Real Fire Island Lighthouse – Fire Island, New York
At 168 feet, Fire Island Lighthouse is the tallest lighthouse in New York. For decades it was the first American landmark seen by ships arriving from Europe. The current tower was first lit in 1858, and on clear days visitors who climb its 182 steps can see the New York City skyline.
Our Amish-Made Fire Island Replica
Our replica reproduces its black-and-white horizontal bands and black lantern. Pair it with Montauk Point for a Long Island set.
Built to Order by Amish Craftsmen in Pennsylvania
Choose a height from 2' to 12', with or without a decorative base. Every lighthouse includes a standard light with a 25W bulb, socket and 8' cord. Upgrade to a dusk-to-dawn sensor, solar LED light, solar light with interior lighting, solar rotating light or electric revolving beacon (3' and up), an extra-large revolving light (8' and 12'), or add interior tower lighting that makes the whole tower glow at night.
- Maintenance-free poly lumber made from 95% recycled material – never needs painting and won't rot, splinter or fade
- 316 marine-grade stainless steel fasteners
- 5-year residential warranty
- Free shipping – ships in about 3–4 weeks
This style is also available in painted wood and hybrid (poly and wood) – see the matching lighthouses below.
Sizes
| Height | Footprint & height | With decorative base |
|---|---|---|
| 2' | 12" x 12" x 24" | 13" x 13" x 27" |
| 3' | 16" x 16" x 36" | 18" x 18" x 40" |
| 4' | 21" x 21" x 48" | 22" x 22" x 53" |
| 5' | 22" x 22" x 60" | 24" x 24" x 67" |
| 6' | 25" x 25" x 72" | 27" x 27" x 84" |
| 8' | 34" x 34" x 96" | 36" x 36" x 114" |
| 12' | 49" x 49" x 144" | 51" x 51" x 158" |
Sizes are approximate (width x depth x height). Poly 5' is 57" tall (65" with base).
Amish-Made Lighthouse Size Chart – Choose Your Perfect Height
All measurements are approximate. Interior dimensions are perfect for covering wells, septic vents, or utilities.
| Lighthouse Height |
Lighthouse Body Only | With Optional Base (Most Popular) | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Exterior (W × H) |
Interior (W × H) |
Base Size (W × H) |
Overall Dimensions with Base |
|
| 12 ft | 49" × 144" | 40" × 109" (36" W at 2' high) |
51" × 24" | 51" × 51" × 158" (14 ft total height) |
| 8 ft | 34" × 96" | 28" × 79" (23" W at 2' high) |
36" × 24" | 36" × 36" × 114" (9 ft 6 in total) |
| 6 ft | 25" × 72" | 20" × 48" (15" W at 2' high) |
27" × 12" | 27" × 27" × 84" (6 ft 10 in total) |
| 5 ft | 25" × 60" | 20" × 48" (15" W at 2' high) |
24" x 10" | 22" × 22" × 57" (5 ft 7 in total) |
| 4 ft | 20" × 48" | 15" × 29" (8" W at 2' high) |
22" × 8" | 22" × 22" × 53" (4 ft 5 in total) |
| 3 ft | 15.5" × 36" | 10" × 19" | 18" × 6" | 16" × 16" × 34" (3 ft 4 in total) |
| 2 ft | 12" × 24" | 8" × 12" | 13" × 4" | 13" × 13" × 27" (2 ft 3 in total) |
Looking for something even taller or fully custom?
We build lighthouses up to 30+ feet high and can replicate any real lighthouse.
Contact us for a free quote!





































































































Login and Registration Form